Does Heel Striking Cause IT Band Pain? YES!

In running, the main cause of IT band pain is when the IT Band compresses the knee’s outer fat pad, resulting in pain and swelling to the area. This issue arises in a crossover running stride, which means the foot lands across the midline, instead of on the midline, or slightly away from the midline, shown below:

The big issues with a crossover running gait is it causes the shin to rotate too far inwardly during stance, which causes the IT band to compresses the fat pad and peripheral nerves in the area, while preventing blood flow from passing through. The only way around this is to avoid heel striking, and instead, land with a forefoot strike. Here’s why:

How Heel strike Running Causes IT Band Pain vs Forefoot Running — Heel strike running is considered a major cause of IT Band pain because the classic feature of the heel strike is an over-stride, which leaves more time for the foot to swing away from its neutral line and across the midline.

The action of heel striking when running causes the knee to completely unbend, creating a pendulum-like stride where the foot swings and lands too far ahead of the torso (which is also the center mass). The mechanical consequence of the leg’s over-reach upon landing leaves more time for the foot to swing across the midline, which it does.

IT band pain arises when the shin bone bends too far inward when the foot crosses over the midline, which transfers more frictional and tractional forces from the IT band to the knee’s outer fat pat. At the same time, the IT band compresses the fat pad, too, putting additional stress on the area. And, that’s hardly the worst of it because relying on cushioned running shoes can rapidly ratchet up abrupt shifts in heel motions during stance.

As it turns out, material properties of shoe cushioning powerfully influences movement patterns of the foot whereby the more compressible (i.e squishy) the underfoot cushioning is, the more pronounced the problem of over-pronation becomes.

Foot pronation is a fancy science term for too much unwanted straining motions of the foot during the stance phase of running whereby underfoot cushioning is the only factor that unintentionally pushes the foot into extreme positions. This is why stability reinforcements are added to these shoes -to prevent the cushioning from pushing the foot away from its neutral line of tolerance.

These findings complement the growing evidence that affirms heel strike running, especially in thick cushioned running shoes, causes a number of mechanical misalignments that are solely responsible for IT band injury.

What has always been clear is a crossover step pattern is reducible only by landing with a forefoot strike since over-striding is automatically prevented. This is because landing on the balls of the foot (i.e the forefoot) when running, leads to more knee flexion and bend, which in turn, guides the foot in a better position, landing closer to the hips (shown below), not farther ahead, as in heel strike running.

How Forefoot Running Prevents IT Band Injury — Forefoot running improves the mechanical chain of events that accounts for sustainably easing strain off the IT Band. Case in point, forefoot running effectively prevents over-striding by improving knee angle at landing, which shortens stride length, while widening stance width,. These are important assets in protecting the IT Band, and re-affirms that bad mechanics get phased out with forefoot running,

A shorter stride angle engaged by a forefoot strike means there’s less time for the foot to swing way out in front of the hips, instead, the added knee flexion, again, engaged by the forefoot strike, acts like a stopper on the foot, restraining over-reaching by getting the foot to drop closer to your hips.

The biggest takeaway is how we use our foot strike and stride mechanics when running has big implications for IT Band injury. If you’ve been working to get rid of your IT band injury, it takes the combination of a shorter stride length and a wider stance width to improve and resolve symptoms, and forefoot running enhances these parameters; heel strike running impedes them.

Last, but not least, IT Band injury is far from being the only injury caused by heel striking when running. Heel strike running also causes the knee-joint to dangerously overheat, whereas forefoot running is gaining almost universal acclaim for fully resolving and preventing the dreaded runner’s knee. Read more here!

If you’ve enjoyed my post, you’ll love my YouTube channel, here, where I show why forefoot running is better than heel strike running.

References:

Falvey et al. Iliotibial band syndrome: an examination of the evidence behind a number of treatment options. Scand J Med Sci Sports, 2010; 20(4):580-7.

Glodzick, P. Injury spotlight: Iliotibial band syndrome. Running & Fit News, 2009; 27(1): 16.

Meardon et al. Step width alters iliotibial band strain during running. Sports Biomech, 2012; 11(4):464-72.

1 Trackback / Pingback