Is it Better to Run with More or Less Cushion?

The long-standing belief that more cushioning means less impact when running has turned out to be false, especially in runners who heel strike. Heel strike running generates the most net mechanical impact, which was found to compound itself more quickly in thick cushioned running shoes as compared with minimalist shoes, which encourages a less force-intensive, more controlled forefoot strike.

Is it Better to Run with More or Less Cushion?
Because impact levels always exceed tolerance, heel strike runners need all the help they can get to reduce injury. This is why their shoes have more padding under the heel (called a crash-pad) than the front of the shoe, shown below:

Is It Bad To Wear Running Shoes as Everyday Shoes?
To reduce impact in heel strike running, most traditional running shoes have a crash-pad under the heel, which is not only ineffective at absorbing impact, but was found to amplify it, while causing reckless motions of the foot in heel strike runners!


Research (references below article) has found the reason injury rates are too high in heel strike runners is their shoes, regardless of heel-pad thickness, produces too much impact that cannot absolutely be absorbed.  Not only that, the more padding under the heel, the higher the heel height, the more instabilities of the foot at landing, which transfers more torsional and rotational stress up the leg.

In alignment with this, a study by Sterzing et al. in the journal, Footwear Science, found that larger crash-pads did not weaken the heel strike transient force (burst in collision impact at landing), and instead, these shoes caused heel strike runners to land with more force, resulting in an unusually high average loading rate. Based on their data, the researchers noted that experts must refrain from claiming that greater under-heel cushioning reduces impact, because it doesn’t.

The researchers also found that a more effective, long-term strategy for reliably reducing impact is not with thicker crash-pads, but by modifying foot strike as the biggest improvement in sustainably preventing damaging impacts from exceeding tolerance is with switching from heel strike to a forefoot strike (shown below). That said, the benefits of forefoot running has now been more well-reported than the ‘protective benefits’ of cushioned running shoes.

How to Fix Hip Pain From Running? Avoid Heel Striking!
Foot strike pattern in running determines the trajectory of your entire stride mechanics, which in turn, directly influences impact production. Many verifiable detriments of heel strike running (above right) results in a locked-out, unbent knee upon landing. This pushes the foot too far ahead of the body upon landing, causing an over-stride which is the central reason for excessive impact production. At present, researchers have learned forefoot running (above left) reverses the mechanics of heel strike running by enabling the knee-joint to automatically bend and flex at landing. This is the primary way to prevent a high impact over-stride with the elimination of the burst collisional impact that underlies most injuries, especially long bone injuries. By that measure, forefoot striking should be the standard prevention and treatment for running injuries.

kids_prio

The current standard of preventing running-related injuries is cushioned running shoes, but the ongoing research on impact mechanics gives more recognition to the legitimacy of these shoes as being a source of injury, especially if you heel strike when you run. Its more accurate to adopt forefoot running based on the very statically significantly reductions in widespread impact. That said, here are all the injuries forefoot running prevents that are directly caused by heel strike running. 
daylite_hiker
References:

Heidenfelder, J., Sterzing, T., & Milani, T.L. (2010). Crash-pad thickness systematically reduces impact shock in running shoes. Footwear Science, 2(2), 85  91.

Nigg, B.M., Cole, G.K., & Br € uggemann, G.P. (1995). Impact forces during heel-toe running. Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 11, 407  432.

Sterzing et al. Running shoe crash-pad design alters shoe touchdown angles and ankle stability parameters during heel  toe running. Footwear Sci, 2015; 7(2);  81-93.
If you’d like, you can support Run Forefoot and help keep it going by making a donation in any amount of your choosing:

Or, you can support Run Forefoot by shopping at the BEST Barefoot Shoe Brands, and be sure to bookmark these links 🙂

Lonowear: https://lonowear.com/?ref=cedsholh

Saguaro: https://www.saguaro.com/?ref=9bVA8fEkmDvB-I

Vibram FiveFingers: https://amzn.to/3VQLAUI

Vivobarefoot: https://amzn.to/3vycQOY

Be Lenka: https://www.tkqlhce.com/click-7600968-13947200

Xero Shoes: https://xeroshoes.com/go/Run_Forefoot

Iguaneye: https://www.iguaneye.com/?ref=8tfXVc92

Soft Star Shoes: https://shrsl.com/3mp1b

Wilding Shoes: https://bit.ly/3lIygQP

P.S. Don't forget to check out the Run Forefoot Facebook Page, it's a terrific place to ask questions about forefoot running, barefoot running and injury. I'm always happy to help!